Patel Defense Criminal defense attorney
Call Now (317) 917-3141
When You Need Results.

Why it is important to reserve judgment in domestic abuse cases

Readers of our criminal defense blog at Patel Defense likely run across stories routinely that spotlight domestic violence incidents in which an assailant is identified, the case is heard, a jury acts and a criminal conviction is obtained.

There is a flip side to such tales, which is perhaps most notable for its underreporting, to wit: It is uncontested fact that not every abuse claim has merit. We duly note on our website -- and from long-tenured experience -- that, "In many cases, domestic violence charges are exaggerated." In some contested divorce matters, for example, "one spouse can exaggerate a domestic abuse situation to win a future custody battle."

Such outcomes are not spotlighted to minimize the unquestionably serious problem of family abuse across the United States. Rather, they are passed along only because they are true and necessitate this very important mindset in any domestic violence matter: the reservation of judgment until all the material facts are known.

Here is a recent on-point case that is directly relevant to the above paragraphs. A businessman was accused by his wife last year of abusing her. A city prosecutor acted upon that information, bringing the man to trial and obtaining a criminal conviction.

There was a problem with that, namely this: the man was innocent, and the prosecutor knew it early on; in fact, she charged the wife with filing a false report even before she brought the man to trial.

And she never passed along the exculpatory evidence to his attorneys.

That was manifestly bad faith, the man contends. He recently filed a notice -- in the wake of his conviction being vacated -- seeking state bar review of the prosecutor's misconduct, which that organization says it will review. Additionally, he is demanding a $5 million settlement from the city.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Patel Defense Criminal defense attorney

Patel Defense
151 N. Delaware Street
Suite 1620
Indianapolis, IN 46204

Phone: (317) 917-3141
Fax: (317) 489-3511
Map & Directions

Lead Counsel | LC | Rated

When your future is on the line, we’re here to help.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

back to top