Patel Defense Criminal defense attorney
Call Now (317) 917-3141
When You Need Results.

Does anyone really believe forensics lab results are error-free?

Another day, another story.

Forensic laboratory results derived from technical analysis of genetically sampled material (think centrally DNA) are sometimes remarkable for what they can reveal. A drop of blood can solve a crime. Sampled saliva can lead to a killer. A single fingerprint can prove that a criminal suspect was here when he said he was there.

At other times, though, they are equally remarkable for their gross inaccuracy, which is fundamentally driven by human error.

And when that occurs, all that often stands between an innocent criminal suspect and a lengthy prison term is a practiced defense attorney who is properly suspicious of all state's evidence and who demands that every alleged truth be proven as such beyond all reasonable doubt.

Police laboratories are certainly high profile in the public mind, given their recurring portrayal in crime dramas and the media as highly sophisticated environments where polished technicians practice scientific art that leads to precisely accurate and infallible conclusions.

That assessment, most reasonable people in Indiana and elsewhere now know, is nonsense. People make mistakes, and they make them in laboratories just as they do elsewhere.

With one fundamental difference: a lab-based error can yield incalculably harsh consequences for people who don't merit them, even, in some instances, a death sentence.

Given that, it is only proper that faulty police lab processes, procedures and testing protocols be brought to the public's attention when they are discovered.

National news outlets did exactly that recently by revealing the suspension of one lab director at a prominent forensics facility. Analysts working under that individual's supervision were reportedly using out-of-date methods for analyzing DNA.

Investigators also discovered that, while serving as a national auditor for crime laboratories, she gave a passing score to one facility where it was later determined that employees lacked required training and were similarly using improper statistical and scientific methods in their work.

It is a core component of an experienced criminal defense attorney's job to ensure that forensic evidence-- indeed, all evidence -- offered by authorities to support an allegation of criminal misconduct is subjected to a thorough vetting and proved to be true.

If it can't clear that hurdle, it needs to be immediately spotlighted for what it patently is -- bogus science that has no place in an arena where an individual's freedom and reputation are at stake.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Patel Defense Criminal defense attorney

Patel Defense
151 N. Delaware Street
Suite 1620
Indianapolis, IN 46204

Phone: (317) 917-3141
Fax: (317) 489-3511
Map & Directions

Lead Counsel | LC | Rated

When your future is on the line, we’re here to help.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

back to top